Water-Resistant vs. Waterproof Backpacks: A Guide to Choosing the Right Gear

When it comes to choosing a backpack, especially for outdoor adventures, everyday commuting, or traveling, one essential consideration is how well the bag protects its contents from moisture. Knowing the difference between “water-resistant” and “waterproof” can help you make the best choice for your needs.

Understanding Water Resistance and Waterproofing

1. Water-Resistant Backpacks
Water-resistant backpacks offer a level of protection against light rain or splashes. They’re typically made from materials like polyester or nylon, treated with a durable water repellent (DWR) coating that sheds light moisture. However, water-resistant backpacks aren’t built to withstand heavy rain or full submersion in water.

  • Ideal Use: Water-resistant backpacks are best for daily commutes, city travel, and light outdoor use. They provide enough protection to keep belongings dry during short periods of rain, making them a practical choice for situations where complete waterproofing isn’t required.
  • Benefits: They are usually lighter and more breathable than waterproof backpacks, offering a good balance of weather resistance and comfort.

2. Waterproof Backpacks
Waterproof backpacks are designed to protect contents in much harsher conditions. They’re typically made with materials such as PVC, tarpaulin, or TPU-coated nylon, and feature heat-sealed or welded seams. Waterproof backpacks often have roll-top closures or special zippers that prevent water entry, offering full protection even when submerged.

  • Ideal Use: These backpacks are best for intense outdoor activities like kayaking, rafting, or hiking in rainy climates, where exposure to heavy rain or water immersion is expected.
  • Benefits: They offer a higher level of protection against water, keeping valuable items like electronics, documents, and clothing completely dry in adverse weather or water conditions.

Key Differences Between Water-Resistant and Waterproof Backpacks

FeatureWater-ResistantWaterproof
MaterialNylon, polyester with DWR coatingPVC, TPU, or tarpaulin
Seam ConstructionStandard stitchingWelded or heat-sealed seams
Closure TypeZippers with flaps, regular zippersRoll-top closure or waterproof zippers
Protection LevelLight rain and splashesFull submersion, heavy rain
Ideal UseEveryday commuting, mild outdoor useWater sports, intense outdoor activities
WeightLighterHeavier due to additional waterproofing

Pros and Cons

  • Water-Resistant Backpacks
  • Pros: Lightweight, often more affordable, sufficient for light weather protection.
  • Cons: Won’t protect against heavy rain or immersion, may not be suitable for rugged outdoor use.
  • Waterproof Backpacks
  • Pros: Excellent protection in extreme wet conditions, durable materials and construction.
  • Cons: Heavier, bulkier, typically more expensive.

Recommended Water-Resistant and Waterproof Backpacks

Here’s a list of six high-quality backpacks to consider, with three options each for water-resistant and waterproof designs.


Top 3 Water-Resistant Backpacks

  1. Patagonia Black Hole Backpack 25L
  • Features: Made from recycled polyester with a water-resistant finish, this backpack is durable and stylish. It has ample storage, including a padded laptop sleeve and multiple pockets.
  • Best For: Urban commuters, light outdoor use.
  • Price Range: Varies
  1. Herschel Little America Backpack
  • Features: With a durable polyester shell and a padded, fleece-lined laptop compartment, this backpack is perfect for daily use in light rain.
  • Best For: Commuters, students, and city travel.
  • Price Range: Varies
  1. Osprey Daylite Plus Backpack
  • Features: This versatile daypack is water-resistant, with a compact design and comfortable harness system. It’s ideal for light hiking and everyday commuting.
  • Best For: Light outdoor activities, travel.
  • Price Range: $60-$75

Top 3 Waterproof Backpacks

  1. YETI Panga Backpack 28
  • Features: Made with thick, high-quality TPU-laminated nylon and a HydroLok zipper, this backpack is entirely waterproof. Its rugged design is perfect for wet and rugged outdoor conditions.
  • Best For: Water sports, hiking in wet environments.
  • Price Range: Varies
  1. SealLine Urban Waterproof Backpack
  • Features: This roll-top waterproof backpack is made from durable, PVC-free materials. It’s fully submersible and designed for those who need ultimate protection in waterlogged conditions.
  • Best For: Kayaking, fishing, rainy hikes.
  • Price Range: Varies
  1. Ortlieb Atrack 25L Waterproof Backpack
  • Features: This pack is IP67-rated for waterproofing and features a unique zipper closure that keeps everything dry. It’s durable and designed for heavy-duty outdoor use.
  • Best For: Intense outdoor adventures, river crossings.
  • Price Range: Varies

Choosing the Right Backpack for Your Needs

When deciding between water-resistant and waterproof backpacks, consider the activities you’ll use the backpack for and the typical weather conditions you’ll face. Here are some guidelines:

  1. For Daily Use: If you’re looking for a backpack to use primarily in urban settings or for a daily commute, a water-resistant option is generally sufficient. It will handle light rain and splashes while keeping the weight low and offering greater comfort for extended wear.
  2. For Outdoor Adventures: If you’re planning on taking your backpack on hikes or outdoor excursions, it’s wise to choose a waterproof backpack, especially if your adventures involve water crossings, boating, or activities where heavy rain is likely.
  3. For Mixed Use: If you need a backpack that’s versatile for both daily use and the occasional outdoor activity, consider a water-resistant backpack with a rain cover. Many brands offer additional protection without the weight and expense of a fully waterproof backpack.

Conclusion

Understanding the differences between water-resistant and waterproof backpacks allows you to choose the right protection level for your needs. Whether you’re navigating city streets or exploring the great outdoors, there’s a backpack out there that fits the job. Investing in a high-quality bag will ensure that your belongings stay dry, safe, and secure, no matter what weather or conditions come your way.

View our shop

Categories: ,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *